The cemetery is located on private property in Bethelboro, North Union Township, Fayette County, PA. Supposedly the farm was once owned by a Judge Swearingen. In addition to the 10 stones listed below, there were 4 square cut fieldstones that were more than likely gravestones, however, there was no visible engraving.
| Surname | Given Name(s) | Born | Died | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| B. | M. | Possible footstone for ? | ||
| Dawson | Elenor | In Memory of | ||
| Dawson | George | In Memory of | ||
| N. | M. | Possible footstone for Mathew Noely | ||
| Noely | Mathew | Aug. 15, 1826 | Aged 76y | |
| S. | J. S. | Possible footstone for Jane S. Swearingen | ||
| Swearingen | Eliza | In Memory of | ||
| Swearingen | Elizabeth Dawson | Feb. 29, 1762 | Feb. 14, 1848 | Wife of William Swearingen |
| Swearingen | Jane S. | Aug. 13, 1823 | Aged 23y 5m | |
| Swearingen | William | Oct. 30, 1768 | Jul. 4, 1841 | |
| Todd | Alexander | Oct. 7, 1810 | Aged 42y |