Directions: From the intersection of Rt 119 and Rt 982 north of Connellsville, go north on Rt 119 for 2.45 miles and turn right on Crossroads Road. Go 0.15 miles to stop and turn right on Ritchie Road. Go 0.25 miles and turn left on Country Club Lane. Go 0.1 miles and the cemetery is on the right. Pennsville Baptist Cemetery is between the parking lot and the shed behind the church. Pennsville Independent Cemetery goes from the shed further down the hill. There are TWO separate cemeteries.
GPS Location:
40.08483 N
79.55726 W
| Surname | Given Name(s) | Born | Died | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adams | Charlie | 13 Jun 1909 | 3 Nov 1926 | |
| Adams | Clarissa K | 13 Jun 1847 | 27 Apr 1905 | w/o R. H. Adams |
| Adams | Robert H | 4 Mar 1844 | 4 Sep 1908 | |
| Anderson | Catherine | ???? | ???? | |
| Anderson | Charlotte J | ?? May 1823 | 3 Nov 1907 | |
| Anderson | Clarence | 18 Sep 1878 | 25 Sep 1891 | |
| Anderson | Margaret A | 28 Apr 183? | Consort of John Anderson | |
| Anderson | unk | 1849 | ||
| Atkinson | Christian | 25 Jul 1862 | ||
| Bixler | Christian S | 4 Dec 1876 | s/o J. & S. Bixler | |
| Bixler | Jesse | 17 Sep 1880 | ||
| Bixler | John D | 10 ? 1871 | ||
| Bixler | Lizzie | 16 Dec 1876 | ||
| Bixler | Sarah | 3 Aug 1887 | ||
| Booher | Andrew | 25 Apr 1870 | s/o C & J | |
| Bowers | Conrad Jr | 7 Jul 1875 | ||
| Bowers | Conrad, Sr | 19 Mar 1805 | ||
| Bowers | Elizabeth | ???? | ||
| Bowman | Amanda J. | 1865 | 1928 | |
| Bowman | Charles H | 30 Nov 1884 | 9 Nov 1965 | US Navy |
| Bowman | Dora L. | 1860 | 1892 | |
| Bowman | Henry | 1815 | 1909 | |
| Bowman | James S. | 1858 | 1956 | |
| Brawner | Jennie | 1862 | 1970 | |
| Brawner | Ross G. | 1855 | 1913 | |
| Bungard | Mary E. | 1849 | 1910 | |
| Byerly | Margaret | 11 Aug 1876 | ||
| Byerly | Michael | 1876 | ||
| Coller | Edgar C. | 8 Nov 1879 | ||
| Coller | William | 6 Mar 1884 | ||
| Cooper | Alfred | 1 Apr 1853 | ||
| Coughenour | Belle M. | 27 May 1867 | 20 Feb 1950 | |
| Coughenour | Harry S. | 24 Dec 1863 | 14 Mar 1944 | |
| Coughenour | Isaiah | 5 Dec 1872 | ||
| Coughenour | James A. | 1866 | 1928 | |
| Coughenour | Jennie | 17 Jul 1880 | ||
| Coughenour | Noble W. | 1890 | 1906 | |
| Cunningham | Sarah | 10 Jun 1800 | 17 May 1852 | |
| Deemer | Leonard | 1847 | 1909 | |
| Deemer | Mary A. | 1849 | 1919 | |
| Echard | Catharine | 11 Jun 1846 | 21 Nov 1906 | |
| Echard | George | 22 Jun 1820 | 23 Mar 1898 | |
| Eicher | Ariann | ???? | ||
| Eicher | Sarah A. | 21 Jul 1873 | ||
| Fleming | Mary | 2 Jul 1809 | 25 Jan 1890 | |
| Foust | Cyrus | 28 Jun 1846 | 28 Dec 1881 | |
| Foust | Elizabeth | 4 Aug 1890 | ||
| Foust | Hiram | 23 Sep 1??? | ||
| Foust | John | 18 May 1870 | ||
| Freed | A. Jr. | |||
| Freed | Abraham | ???? | ||
| Freed | Anna | ???? | w/o Henry A. Freed | |
| Freed | Lydia | 26 Apr 1830 | w/o Robert | |
| Freed | Robert | 18 June 1892 | ||
| Gault | John | ???? | ||
| Hall | ???? | ???? | ||
| Hall | Aida May | 6 Sep 1837 | ||
| Hall | Charley | 23 Sep 1871 | ||
| Halley | Cora E. | 1860 | 1886 | |
| Halley | James W. | 1853 | 1930 | |
| Harbaugh | Rachel A. | 1836 | 1921 | |
| Harbaugh | Victor S. | 1836 | 1913 | |
| Hixon | Isahia | 18 Oct 1868 | ||
| Howard | Charley | 9 Oct 1872 | 18 Oct 1873 | |
| Hughes | Elizabeth Howell | 4 Sep 1876 | ||
| Ingles | William H. | 9 Jun 1867 | 4 Oct 1895 | |
| Keacy | Elizabeth | 22 May 1811 | ||
| Keacy | John | 1890 | ||
| Keacy | Susanna | 1797 | 1883 | |
| Kelley | Alexander C. | 1 Dec 1866 | ||
| Kelley | Paul | 1869 | ||
| Kelly | ??? | ???? | ||
| Kelly | Alexander | 20 May 1760 | 29 Jul 1850 | |
| Kelly | C. | 24 Dec 1816 | 6 Apr 1905 | |
| Kelly | Catharine | 9 Aug 1845 | Consort of Alexander Kelly | |
| Kelly | Catherine Campbell | 24 Dec 1783 | 9 Aug 1845 | |
| Kelly | Lavinia Highlands | 1 May 1819 | 7 Dec 1898 | w/o Washington Kelly |
| Kelly | Sarah | 17 Sep 1891 | w/o C. Kelly | |
| Kelly | Washington P. | 26 Jul 1815 | 1 Jun 1897 | |
| Kennady | Caroline | 30 Mar 1846 | ||
| Kodser | Sarah | 2 Oct 1880 | w/o Peter Kodser | |
| Lane | Eli | 1849 | 1852 | |
| Lane | Emma | 1860 | 1862 | |
| Lane | Henry | Sep 1821 | ||
| Lane | John | 1862 | 1926 | |
| Lane | Lewis W. | 1853 | 1862 | |
| Lane | Mary | 1858 | 1862 | |
| Latimer | Eleanor | ???? | ||
| Latimer | Rebecca | 15 Feb 18?? | 29 Jun 18?? | |
| Latimer | Robert | 1 Oct 1825 | 22 May 1888 | s/o of J & J |
| Laughe_ | John | 31 May 1867 | ||
| Laughrey | Robert | 1809 | 1862 | |
| Laughrey | Sarah | 1805 | 1873 | |
| Lindsay | Mary | 1884 | w/o David Lindsay | |
| Lyon | Elizabeth | 21 Aug 1867 | w/o W. G. | |
| McClary | Blanche | 14 Sep 1885 | 8 Nov 1897 | d/o E. & C. E. |
| McClary | Edd | 1872 | 1899 | |
| McClellan | David | 27 Dec 1872 | s/o H & Amanda | |
| McGoogan | Ada M. | 1892 | 1893 | |
| McGoogan | James C. | 8 Jul 1858 | ? Apr 1900 | |
| McGoogan | Otto | 1894 | 1908 | |
| Miller | Elizabeth | 1833 | 1895 | |
| Miller | George | ? Jun ???? | ||
| Miller | Jonas | 1820 | 1890 | |
| Miller | Malachi | 12 Jul 1882 | ||
| Miller | Nancy A. | 2 Mar 1877 | ||
| Murray | Mary Echard | 1851 | 1899 | |
| Myers | John C. | 1859 | 1938 | |
| Myers | Mollie F. | 1862 | 1938 | |
| Newmyer | Harriet | 1850 | ||
| Newmyer | Jonathan | 15 May 1879 | ||
| Newmyer | Mary S. | 3 Oct 1863 | ||
| Newmyer | Peter | 16 Aug 1815 | ||
| Newmyer | Peter | 15 Mar 1836 | ||
| Newmyer | Susanah | 23 Mar 1838 | ||
| Ogle | Sarah A. | 1841 | 1890 | |
| Pickard | Mahala | 1853 | 1895 | |
| Pippit | John | 25 May 1835 | ||
| Pippitt | Isaac | 1839 | ||
| Pippitt | John | 25 Apr 1823 | ||
| Pippitt | Lucretia | ???? | ||
| Pippitt | Susan | 9 Aug 1839 | ||
| Pippitt | William | 1844 | ||
| Pollins | Elizabeth | 5 Mar 1794 | 6 Feb 1840 | |
| Pollins | Hannah | Apr 1834 | ||
| Pollins | William | 15 Jul 1785 | 20 Oct 1871 | |
| Ralston | Paul R. | 12 Oct 1900 | 25 Sep 1902 | s/o C. R. & S. |
| Reece | Archey | 24 Jan 18?? | ||
| Reece | Margaret | 27 Nov 1874 | w/o Andrew | |
| Richey | David | 10 Jul 1872 | ||
| Richey | Sophia | 9 Feb 1882 | ||
| Ritenour | Harriet C. | 9 Jan 1888 | ||
| Schaffer | Freeman L. | 22 Feb 1851 | ||
| Shaffer | Henry | 9 Jul 1853 | ||
| Shallenberger | J. Darsie | 17 Apr 1846 | ||
| Shallenberger | James | 29 Nov 1834 | ||
| Shallenberger | James | 19 Nov 1830 | ||
| Shallenberger | Mary | 12 Feb 1850 | ||
| Shank | Abraham | 18 Jul 1814 | ||
| Shank | Catharine | 22 Apr 1893 | ||
| Shank | Christena | 24 Aug 1819 | ||
| Shank | Christian | 5 Sep 1810 | 14 Feb 1909 | |
| Shank | David | 30 Oct 1835 | ||
| Shank | Elizabeth | 15 Feb 1884 | ||
| Shank | Jacob | 1864 | 1892 | |
| Shank | Jacob | 1 Sep 1845 | ||
| Shank | John | ???? | ||
| Shank | Margaret B. | 21 Jan 1846 | 3 Jan 1864 | |
| Shank | Nancy | 8 Jun 1866 | ||
| Slonecker | ??? | ???? | ||
| Slonecker | Alexander | ???? | ||
| Slonecker | Jacob | ???? | 12 Jul 1865 | |
| Slonecker | Mary | 22 Feb 1891 | ||
| Suttle | Harry Newton | 8 Apr 1881 | ||
| Taylor | Elizabeth | 10 Feb 1876 | ||
| Taylor | John, Sr. | 19 May 1885 | ||
| Taylor | Mary E. | 11 Feb 1863 | ||
| Taylor | Willie | ???? | ||
| Volts | Annie M. | 2 Feb 1896 | ||
| Weaver | Patrick | ???? | ||
| Wilson | David | 13 Jan 1890 | ||
| Yard | Sarah J. | 1847 | 1874 | w/o W. S. |
| Yates | Infant Girl | 4 Jul 1846 | ||
| Yates | Philip | Mar 1832 | Nov 1898 |