Mt Pleasant/Winslow Hill Cemetery Benezette Township  Elk County PA

Mt Pleasant Cemetery also known as Winslow Hill Cemetery, Benezette Township, Elk Co., PA as read by Bob Nay and family/ relatives over the past couple years. Please if you see any errors or missing information let me know so I can correct as much as possible. Also thanks to Iris and Sarah Caskey for permission to use their previous publications to supplement and check my readings. So any help is appreciated to keep this list up to date.

Tombstone photos have been added and are identifed with a highllighted last name. Just click the name to see the photo.


A Special Noted Burial: TISHA Jan 1, 1991- Aug 19, 2004 under the tree

The cemetery is located on Rt 20004 about 1.5 miles up Winslow Hill from the Benezette Hotel around a sharp turn as you reach the top of the hill. The GPS coordinates are: N41 20'34" W78 21' 53" .
Last Name First/Middle Name Born Died Other  
Belcher Addie (abt Mar 2, 1872) June 11, 1872 3m 9d; d/o SB and E C.  
Bonfardine Joseph; 1907 1985    
Bonfardine Hazel V. 1909 1998    
Booth John 1820 1901    
Booth Eunice 1819 1901 w/o John  
Booth Lelia B. January 7, 1884 2y 11m 12d ;d/o B.A. and E.  
Carraway Rev. William E. 1920 1999(or 79) PFC 1340 SCU Med. Det  
Copello Toni Michelle July 13, 1999(1) Baby  
Dudley LeRoy F. 1906 1974 Father  
Dudley Vivian F. 1911 2005 Mother  
Easton Leon Leroy Mar 21, 1930 Jun 22, 2000 Cpl US Marine Corps Korea; s/o Leonard and Louise Easton  
Fenice Pamela A Jan 3, 1949 May 3, 2007    
Fey Wesley Sr Oct 23, 1944 Sep 24, 2003    
Fenice Pamela A Jan 3, 1949 May 3, 2007    
Goff Rhoba Nichols Mar. 26, 1779 Sep. 5, 1834 wife of Potter Goff  
Hanscom Dana B. 1872 1949 Father  
Hanscom Addie S Unreadable Unreadable d/o J M and E M  
Harrison Freda Losey 1915 1941 Mother  
Hauber Finley S 1959 1985    
Hicks Jesse L. February 16, 1926 December 29, 1998    
Hicks Etta C.   September 2, 1915    
Hicks Henry A. 1869 1951    
Hicks John M. 1837 unk    
Hicks Alzina R. 1841 1918 w/o John  
Hicks Julia A. E. 1867 1869    
Hicks Jennie E. 1871 1891    
Hicks Geraldean O. 1902 1907    
Hicks Cl(ar)a S. December 22, 1889 2y 9m 1d, d/o E. W. and R A  
Hicks Infant   March 18, 1880 s/o EW and RA Hicks  
Hicks Clyda S   Dec 22, 1863(83) 2 yrs 9 m; s/o EW and R.A (Hicks)  
Hollingsworth Unreadable 1877      
Hollingsworth Infant (Apr. 8, 1891) April 29, 1891 3 w(eeks); s/o FV and OJ  
Hollingsworth Alzina Murray July 17, 1846 May 23, 1912 w/o J. C.  
Hollingsworth Basil C. August 5, 1908 September 29, 1908 Son of D & E A Hollingsworth  
Hollingsworth Delbert M. (Apr 7, )1870 (Apr 20,)1951 Dad  
Hollingsworth Ellen H. Nov. 26, 1871 October 2, 1871 2y 10m 4d ; d/o I and A  
Hollingsworth Eulalia A. September 10, 1872 December 20, 1912 w/o Delbert  
Hollingsworth Frank V. 1868 1919    
Hollingsworth George E June 21, 1881 December 13, 1883 s/o of I and A  
Hollingsworth Harlon I(or J). Jan 18,1826(76) January 25,1903  
Hollingsworth Hiram Sep. 24, 1837 May 24, 1905 66y 8m  
Hollingsworth Isaac 1842 1863 died while serving in the Civil War  
Hollingsworth Isaiah Coleman Jun. 16, 1845 Jul. 31, 1929 (coming to this part of the country when lumbering was the chief industry)  
Hollingsworth Lottie 1896 1977 w/o Paul  
Hollingsworth Murray V.   June 8, 1907 son of D.M and E. A.  
Hollingsworth Orpha J. 1869 1945 w/o Frank  
Hollingsworth Paul 1894 1957 h/o Lottie  
Hollowell Olive L. 1910 1973    
Hons Ralph J. 1911 1914    
Johnson Adaline Jemima Overturf May 27, 1845 February 19, 1915 69y 8 m 23 d; w/o David S  
Johnson Carol December 20, 1932 April 11, 1995 Reibsome  
Johnson Coleman T. October 16, 1824 September 5, 1903    
Johnson David Summerson Jul. 13, 1837 December 21, 1906 69y 5 m 9d  
Johnson Massey   May 21, 1896 84y 5 m 26 d; w/o M. Duke  
Johnson M. Duke   September 17, 1890 76y, 5m, 17d.  
Johnson Paul D. December 3, 1929 October 29, 2002  
Johnson Sarah H March 17, 1831 May 28, 1922    
Johnson Simpson 1804 1860    
Johnson Therza M. Woodworth 1819 1860 w/o Simpson  
Johnston Orson R Nov 28, 1870 7y 9d; s/o FH and AH  
Johnston (infant) Mar 19, 1867 Mar 19, 1867 s/o FH and AH  
Jordan Almina M. 1846 1921 grandmother of Robert A; w/o William R  
Jordan Charles M 1910 1998 US Army WW2  
Jordan C. Elaine 1930 1983    
Jordan Eva A. (Hicks) 1878 1922    
Jordan Robert A. 1917 1921 grandson  
Jordan William J. 1865 1914    
Jordan William K 1837 1916 grandfather  
King Joseph Edward Jun. 18, 1840 Oct. 16, 1900  
King Sarah Jane Boyer Jun. 7, 1844 Sep. 4, 1892 Wife of Joseph Edward King  
Krebs Jane Montgomery Hollingsworth 1812 December 18, 1899 87 yr; buried between her sons Hiram and Isaac  
Krise Ariel E. 1893 1974  
Kunes Shirley A Nov 9, 1946 Nov 17, 2002 Dudley  
Kunes Clayton F Jan 2, 1946   US Army  
Mack "John F. "Bud" 1953 1992 Son  
Mack Mary D Snider 1948   daughter  
Mack Roy J. Sr. 1928 Apr 28, 1995(3) Father;(Korea)  
Mack Edythe M. 1920 2004 Mother  
Mc Cracken George 1909 1988    
Mc Cracken Henry G. Jun 25, 1940 Feb 1993    
Mc Cracken Jacob S 1973 1999    
Mc Cracken Marjorie 1921 1998    
McCracken Nora M. October 19, 1884 August 2, 1952    
Mc Cracken Wayne C Sep. 25, 1943 Feb. 20, 2009 married to Harriet L. Ward McCracken  
Milkovich Pete July 1, 1921 Aug 22, 1995 Married June 30, 1951 Vet WW2  
Milkovich Joyce 1931 2008    
Mowrey Ransom A. 1851 1917    
Mowrey Isabel 1859 1927 w/o Ransom  
Mowrey Harry A. 1880 1915  
Murphy Marlene Larken July 11, 1945 January 1, 1990    
Murray Hiram O. 1859 1920 Father  
Overturf William Oren 1943      
Overturf John W. 1845 1916    
Overturf Ellias W Nov 5, 1871 21y 6m 5d; s/o J and D  
Overturf Sarah E. 1856   w/o John W.  
Overturf Sadie C January 15, 1880 4m 9 d; d/o JW and SE  
Overturf Harriet M. 1913 1971    
Overturf Clair F. 1912 1989    
Overturf Oscar F. 1880 1962    
Overturf Lulu H. 1891 1919    
Overturf Angel May 7, 1965 May 7, 1965 d/o John & Patricia  
Overturf Julia E. 1855 1937    
Overturf William J 1849 1932    
Overturf John W March 16, 1938 Feb 19, 2006 PFC US Army ; Lovingly known as Jack  
Overturf Sylvia Emeline 1890 1923    
Overturf Lillie K Solomon 1943 1975    
Overturf Delilah   March 25, 1899 75y 3 m 14 d; w/o James  
Overturf James October 1, 1819 October 23, 1884 65y 23 d.  
Overturf James Orville December 3, 1944 August 3, 1992 (Vietnam)  
Petreni Richard Allen September 8, 1958 July 19, 1982 Our Beloved Rich ;In Gods Hands we place you  
Poole Rev H Gerald Jr July 25,1950 Oct 28,2005 married Oct 13, 1978; (Vietnam)  
Poole Diane L Dec 31, 1957    
Reibsome Carol Johnson December 20, 1932 April 11, 1995  
Richardson Daniel E. January 4, 1905 March 21, 1968 Pennsylvania PVT Coast Artillery WW1  
Richardson Lola May November 28, 1914 May 7, 1972 Beloved Mother  
Rothrock Melvin E. 1911 1985    
Rothrock Louise E. 1917 1981    
Rothrock Mary Ann Aug 1848 1941 Mother; nee Wilson; h/o George T; d/o Harbison and Jane Johnson Wilson of Winslow Hill  
Rothrock George T. May 11, 1841 Feb. 20, 1923 Father; h/o Fannie A. Rothrock (1842 - 1867) Mary Ann Wilson Rothrock (1848 - 1937)  
Rothrock Fannie A Jun. 4, 1842 May 1, 1867 24y 11m 27d; w/o George T  
Rothrock Ida E (abt Apr. 8, 1871 ) June 14, 1876 5y 2m 6d; d/o GT and MA  
Rothrock Jennie A ( abt Jun. 22, 1869) June 23, 1870 1y 1d; d/o GT and MA  
Rothrock John W (abt Apr. 24, 1875) June 4, 1876 1y 1m 11d; s/o GT and MA  
Rothrock Nellie (Oct. 31, 1865) June 3, 1876 10y 7m 3d; d/o CE and FA  
Sidelinger Vera Donnell   March 27, 1945    
Smith Mary M 1905 1905  
Snider Mary D.   1948 Daughter  
Solomon Lillie K. 1943 1975    
Stumpf Harry H. September 7, 1922 April 26, 2000 US Navy World War II  
Stumpf Ada Louise Fetterman September 13, 1928 January 8, 1993    
Sutch Ann Marlay 1937 1969 Death lies on her as an untimely frost upon the sweetest flower of all the field.  
Swackhammer Arley R 1932      
Swackhammer Darlene M 1937 2004 < /td>  
Tuttle Leslie S. September 25, 1897 July 14, 1973 Father  
Tuttle Agnes T. December 1, 1899 March 27, 1990 Mother; (Winslow)  
Tuttle Helen V. June 8, 1931 Daughter  
Tuttle Judson A. 1890 1925 Amb. Co. No. 30, 5th Div AEF WW1  
Tuttle John V. 1853 1929  
Tuttle Harriet E. 1860 1904 w/o John Tuttle  
Tuttle Jean M. Nov 17, 1932 June 26, 2002 Walters  
Tuttle Clarence E Apr 19, 1933 Dec 21, 2004 US Army Korea  
Unreadable Fannie A. Unreadable Unreadable    
Unreadable Nellie J. Unreadable Unreadable    
Unreadable       2 old stones  
Van Lew Mack E. 1879 1947    
Van Lew Audra Alzina Apr. 5, 1886 Feb. 24, 1963 nee Hollingsworth; w/o Mack  
Van Lew Robert C Bob Apr 9, 1926 Feb 7, 2005 (WW2);h/o Ora Carol  
Van Lew Ora C Carol Feb 7, 1930   Davis  
Van Voorhis Perry J. February 4, 1964 January 31, 1989    
Van Voorhis Denise A. August 21, 1970 November 18, 1989 daughter  
Van Voorhis Daniel D. June 16, 1941 February 4, 1999    
Van Voorhis Dewey 1898 1984    
Van Voorhis Edna Hazel Woodring Feb 18, 1911 Aug 7, 1995    
Van Voorhis Daniel D June 16, 1941 Feb 4, 1999    
Van Voorhis Thomas R 1943 2002 Tom  
Van Voorhis Carol L 1941   Rucinski  
Van Voorhis Rodney Nov 2, 1939   Army  
Van Voorhis Rita G Jan 20, 1942   McClintick  
Wilson H R   Set 12,1880 61y 7m 12d  
Wilson Jane R   Jan 27,1895 76y 3m 18d; w/o H R  
Wilson Ralph T.   September 15, 1858 3y 3m 12d, s/o H.R and JR  
Wilson Jane E.   September 25, 1863 10y 1m; d/o H.R & J.R.  
Wilson John C. February 12, 1845 October 8, 1868 s/o H.R. & J. R.  
Wilson Hugh F 1846 1913  
Wilson Olive 1851 1915 w/o Hugh  
Winslow Ada Emaline Johnson Sep. 4,1895 Dec. 8,1972 Mother; w/o Merton  
Winslow Ada E.   April 27, 1878 1 y 4 m 1 d;dau/of J. W. & M. E.  
Winslow Beulah   May 16, 1864 68 y 4 m 13d;w/o Carpenter ;Our mother's request is to stand up for Jesus everywhere. Always look to Him.  
Winslow Beulah E Oct 5, 1868 12d; d/o Charles and Rebecca  
Winslow Bruce M 1879 1954 Father  
Winslow Bruce Newell Sep 6, 193x      
Winslow Burton LeRoy 1872 May 12, 1876 son of George Lafayette Winslow b. Oct 10th 1847 in Benezette, Elk County, PA and Martha Ann Lee b. May 14th 1850 in Keating Twp., McKean County, PA.  
Winslow Clarence S. 1852 1927    
Winslow Charles B(enton) 1881 1884    
Winslow Charles K.   April 4, 1869 51y 2m 11 d  
Winslow Clesta 1877 1943 Mother  
Winslow Ebenezer (May 11, 1823) January 8, 1863 39 y 8 m. 27 d  
Winslow Edna M(ay Losey) (Oct)1844 (Feb 16)1929 Mother  
Winslow Elizabeth Newell September 21, 1911 November 24, 1994  
Winslow Ethel M. (1871) August 28, 1881 10y d/o Geo. L. & M. H  
Winslow James S(ylvanus) (Jan. 26), 1883 (Jun. 2), 1968 Father  
Winslow Joshua W.   April 4, 1889 63 y 8 m 30 d  
Winslow Lafayette 1847 1919  
Winslow Leona Irene 1940 1982 Mother, In Loving Memory of  
Winslow Lorena M. 1877 1879    
Winslow Leroy   May 12, 1876 2 y 8 m.;s/o G. L. & M..  
Winslow Losey J(ames) January 19, 1913 April 16, 1971    
Winslow Martha 1850 1926 w/o of Lafayette  
Winslow Mary E(lizabeth)Hicks (Jan. 2, 1826) July 18, 1872 46 y. 6m 7 d;w/o Ebenezer  
Winslow Mary M(artha)(Johnston) (Sep. 4) 1856 (Jun. 9) 1914    
Winslow Merton H(artman) (Jun. 28), 1888 (Aug. 3),1954 Father  
Winslow Minnie August 10, 1872 21 y 2 m 15 d; wife of W. K.  
Winslow Minnie I   March 12, 1877 1y 7m 13d; d/o W. K. and M  
Winslow Rebecca H.   January 13, 1907 80y 2m 11d; w/o Charles K  
Winslow Robert L. 1921 1927    
Winslow Sylvanus G.   July 20,1877 1y 1m 23d; s/o C. A. & M.  
Winslow Thelma Marie Sep 17, 1932 June 27, 2007 Palmer  
Winslow Thomas B. 1836 1876 Civil War; Co C 42, 1st Lt  
Winslow Verna E. 1909 1909    
Winslow Walter Keith 1939 1988 Son, Brother and Father; US Army Korea  
Winslow W(illiam) Kenelm October 24, 1910 January 5, 1993 (Son of Bruce M & Clesta J (English) Winslow; married Elizabeth Newell)  
Winslow William K(eene) (Aug., )1846 (Aug. 3) 1913 Son of Charles Keene & Rebecca (Hicks) Winslow; married Mary Martha Johnston  
Winslow William L. 1909 1909    
Winslow Infant   August 12, 1927    
Wolcott John S. 1851 1936    
Wolcott Rachel R. 1852 1935    
Woodring Lola L. 1891 1970    
Woodring Otto A. 1885 1960    
Woodring Horace H. 1911 1964 T/S Co B 1251st Engs CBT. Bn World War II  
Woodring Dorothy J. March 23, 1922 April 25, 1972  
Woodring David C September 18, 1951 July 4, 1998 Son and Brother  
Woodring Carl C 1928 1970 Father;Cpl. Arty. 2D Army Area Korean War  
Woodring Lavina S. 1914 1940    
Woodring Floyd A. 1922 1945 2nd Lt 398th Sgdn 504th Bombardment Group;WW II Lost over Kobe, Japan  
Woodring Pauline 1914 1914    
Woodring Ruth 1918 1918    
Woodring Ronald 1920 1920    
Woodring Lorane 1916 1926    
Woodring Doris 1929 1929    
Woodring Clifford 1931 1931    
Woodring John A.   February 1, 1910 27y, 2m, 25 d  
Woodring Milford   November 13, 1902 11yr, 1m, 19d;s/o S. J. & H M  
Woodring Harriett M.   October 21, 1893 41y, 6m, 10d.;w/o Samuel  
Woodring Malinda E. April 21, 1866 January 9, 1927  
Woodring Derlin 1893 1958 PFC 2M Corp;WW I  
Woodring Martha J.   December 19, 1908 42 y 10 m 18d;w/o M. D.  
Woodring Jeffrey Todd   September 7, 1975;s/o Rexford and Carol    
Woodring Rexford J. 1912 1972 Father  
Woodring Blanche A July 16, 1921 Dec 1, 2001 Dixon  
Woodring Merle D. Oct 13, 1919   US Navy WW2  
Woodring Maynard M July 13, 1918 May 22, 2003 married 63 yrs  
Woodring Mabelle E March 14, 1919 Jan 9, 2004 Hollingsworth  
Woodring Donna Winslow Jan 3, 1933 Sep 5, 2007    
Woodring Margaret K Oct 22, 1939 July 13, 2006    
Woodring William H March 25, 1938      
Woodring Benjamin R 1886 1979 (WW1)  
Woodring Marie M 1894 1976    

Contributed by Jim Burke and Bob Nay

In keeping with our policy of providing free information on the Internet, data may be freely used by non-commercial entities, as long as this message remains on all copied material. These electronic pages cannot be reproduced in any format for profit or other presentation without permission from the contributors above.

Return to Mt Zion Historical Society Website