Mercer County PAGenWeb


Greenville 

First Presbyterian Church


The Presbyterian Church was organized in 1825, with a membership of thirty-one. Robert Mann and Samuel Webster were elected ruling elders. For a few years it was connected with the old Salem Church, on the Mercer road, the two forming a pastoral charge. From the existing records of the church it appears that the following named members were the pioneers of this organization: Robert Mann, Mary Mann, Samuel Webster, Susannah Webster, Polly Christy, Annie Robinson, Polly Robinson, Martha Lyon, Margaret Williamson, Eliza Latimer, Lydia Cossitt, Elizabeth Haver, Catherine Haver, Jane Heastings, Adam Wier, Mary Ann Wier, Mary Woods, Rebecca Woods, William Woods, Polly Potter, Susannah Potter, Elizabeth Bean, Lettie Bean, William Stinson, Martha Stinson, Jane Brown, Rachael Porter, Rebecca Alexander, John McLaughlin, Lavina McLaughlin and Hannah Robinson.  

First Presbyterian Church
of Greenville -
as it looked in the early 1900's

The first services of the new congregation were held in private houses, then in a log structure, which was erected in 1830, and used by the Methodists of the community. In 1833 a brick building somewhat smaller than the present one, was erected on the present site, and served for over sixteen years, when it became unsafe, and was torn down, after which the present edifice was begun. The latter has been remodeled once (in 1870), and has also undergone several repairs.

Following is a list of the pastors of the congregation since its inception: Revs. James Alexander, 1828-34; James G. Wilson, 1836-42; Henry Webber, 1843-44; L. W.   Williams (supply), 1845- 47; James H. Callen,  1848-52; David Grier, 1854-59; A. C. Junkin, 1862- 87; J. E. Wright, 1869-74; B. C. Critchlow, 1875-81; O. V. Stewart, 1881-87, and the present pastor [1888], Rev. C. B. Wakefield, installed in 1887. Several other ministers filled the pulpit as supplies during the periods when there was no regular pastor. The following persons filled the office of ruling elder since the organization of the church: Robert Mann, 1825-53; Samuel Webster, 1825-32; George Lodge, 1831-54; James Waugh, 1837-46; John B. Plumer, 1837-54; Robert Bean, 1837-46; William Sutton, 1849-53; G. E. Lashell, 1849-61; John Wiley, 1855-74; G. A. Bittenbanner, 1855-88; B. F. Baskin, 1855-59; Samuel Wilson, 1843-44; Joseph Pearce, 1848-59; Thomas  M. Reznor, 1860-88; Henry Moore,  1860-68; John W. Stinson, 1864-66; William Fruit, 1865-66;  Jacob Miller, 1865-74; S. M. Ross, 1868-75; Chambers Templeton, 1871-88; John Love, 1871-88; James Williamson, 1876-88;  M. Dawson Moore, 1876-82; John A. Beatty,  January, 1876-July, 1876; J. E. Brockway, 1885-88, and W. T. Alan, 1885-88. The present elders are: George A. Bittenbanner (not acting), Thomas M. Reznor, Chambers Templeton, John Love, James Williamson, J. E. Brockway and W. T. Alan. It is estimated that 1,100 names have been enrolled on the list of membership since the organization. The present membership is 325. A. flourishing Sunday-school is connected with the church, with about 265 pupils and teachers. J. E. Brockway is superintendent, and E. S. Templeton and A. P. Alan, assistants.

(Source: History of Mercer County, 1888, pages 423-424)

First Presbyterian Church.—This church was organized in 1825, with thirty-one members. The first pastor was Rev. James Alexander, who was ordained and installed October 13th, 1828. Mr. Robert Mann  and Samuel Webster were elected as ruling elders. The congregation first worshiped in a log-house, which had been built and occupied by the Methodists. During the summer season, the congregation frequently worshiped in the grove, on the site of the cemetery, in the rear of the present church edifice. In 1833, they erected a brick house on the site of the present structure. After some years, about 1845, this building became insecure, and was taken down, and the house now [1877] occupied by the congregation erected, which, in 1870, was remodeled and very much improved.  The pastors succeeding Rev. Mr. Alexander, who was released in 1834, have been Rev. J. G. Wilson, ordained and installed October 12th, 1836; released, 1841. Rev. Henry Webber, ordained and installed January 20th, 1843; released, October 16th, 1844. Rev. L. Williams, who supplied the church in 1847-48. Rev. J. H. Callen, ordained and installed October 25th, 1848; released, June 23d,  1852. Rev. , installed January 18th, 1854; released, April 13th, 1859. Rev. A. C. Junkin, installed June  10th, 1862; released; May 8th, 1867. Rev. N. S. McFetridge supplied about six months.Rev. John E. Wright was installed in 1869, and continued until the spring of 1874. Rev. B. C. Critchlow was installed in May, 1875, and is the present [1877] pastor. Membership, 190; Sabbath-school, with four officers, twelve teachers, and about 125 scholars; library of 200 volumes.  (Source: History of Mercer County, 1877,  page 100 - 101)

Return to Churches Home Page

Return to Mercer County Home Page